Recurring vs. Nonrecurring Fair Value Measurements: Examples, Disclosures, and Impairments
Under ASC 820, recurring fair value measurements happen at the end of every reporting period because a standard requires or permits it, like trading securities and derivatives. Nonrecurring measurements happen only when an event triggers them, like an impairment or a held-for-sale write-down. Both disclose the fair value hierarchy level, but only nonrecurring measurements disclose the reason.
This matters because the two types get different notes. Mixing them up leads to errors such as putting an impaired building in the Level 3 reconciliation. This lesson focuses on the impairment disclosures, the most common nonrecurring case. For the three levels themselves, see fair value disclosures: Level 1, Level 2, and Level 3 explained.
Watch: Nonfinancial assets measured at fair value (starts at 5:22, nonfinancial assets measured at fair value)
Watch this Farhat lesson on YouTube
Studying this for the CPA exam or an intermediate accounting class? The full lessons, with more examples, are in the Farhat Lectures Intermediate Accounting course.
Recurring vs. nonrecurring fair value measurements at a glance
| Feature | Recurring | Nonrecurring |
|---|---|---|
| When fair value is measured | At the end of every reporting period | Only when a specific event requires it |
| Examples | Trading securities, available-for-sale debt securities, derivatives, fair value option items | Impaired long-lived assets, the reporting unit fair value used in a goodwill impairment test, assets held for sale written down to fair value less cost to sell |
| Carrying amount afterward | Updated to fair value again next period | Held and used assets: the written-down amount becomes the new cost basis and is never written back up. Held-for-sale assets: initially measured at the lower of carrying amount or fair value less cost to sell. A later increase in fair value less cost to sell is recognized as a gain, capped at the cumulative held-for-sale write-downs. |
| Level 3 reconciliation | Full reconciliation required for public entities. Nonpublic entities separately disclose purchases and issues, and the amounts and reasons for transfers into and out of Level 3. | Not required |
What must each type disclose?
ASC 820 applies to both types of measurement after initial recognition, but not every disclosure applies to both (PwC Viewpoint, FSP 20.3; Deloitte Roadmap, Section 11.1).
| Disclosure | Recurring | Nonrecurring |
|---|---|---|
| Fair value amount | At the end of the period | At the measurement date (and the date, if not period-end) |
| Reason for the measurement | No | Yes |
| Hierarchy level (1, 2, or 3) | Yes | Yes |
| Valuation technique and inputs (Levels 2 and 3) | Yes | Yes |
| Quantitative information about significant unobservable inputs (Level 3) | Yes | Yes |
| Level 3 reconciliation and unrealized gains and losses on items still held | Both required for public entities. Nonpublic entities provide the separate Level 3 disclosures listed in the comparison table in lieu of the full reconciliation. | No |
| Narrative on how changes in unobservable inputs could change fair value (Level 3, public business entities) | Yes | No |
| Highest and best use differs from current use (nonfinancial assets) | Yes | Yes |
Edge cases: what counts as recurring or nonrecurring?
A few situations trip up students and preparers. Here is how each one is classified.
- Assets held for sale remeasured every period. Still nonrecurring. The measurement is triggered by the held for sale classification, not by a standard that requires fair value on the balance sheet. ASC 820’s own illustration presents long-lived assets held for sale as nonrecurring.
- Equity securities under the measurement alternative. Equity securities without a readily determinable fair value can be carried at cost, adjusted for observable price changes and impairment. Each adjustment to fair value is a nonrecurring measurement.
- Business combinations. Fair values recorded at the acquisition date are initial recognition, so they fall outside the ASC 820 recurring and nonrecurring tables. ASC 805 has its own disclosures.
- Items where fair value is only disclosed. A bond payable carried at amortized cost is not measured at fair value on the balance sheet, so it is neither recurring nor nonrecurring. See fair value of financial instruments.
Under IFRS: IFRS 13 uses the same recurring and non-recurring split and also requires the reasons for non-recurring measurements.
Worked example: Westbrook Manufacturing
Hypothetical example. Westbrook Manufacturing ($ in millions) recorded three impairment-related write-downs during the year.
- Equipment held and used: carrying amount $48. The equipment failed the recoverability test, and its fair value, based on prices for similar used equipment, is $36. Impairment loss: $12.
- Warehouse held for sale: carrying amount $20, fair value $17 based on an appraisal with significant unobservable adjustments, cost to sell $1. It is written down to $16. Loss: $4.
- Customer-list intangible: carrying amount $9, fair value $5 from a discounted cash flow model. Impairment loss: $4.
| ($ in millions) | Fair value at measurement date | Level 1 | Level 2 | Level 3 | Total losses |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Equipment held and used | $36 | — | $36 | — | ($12) |
| Warehouse held for sale | 17 | — | — | $17 | (4) |
| Customer-list intangible | 5 | — | — | 5 | (4) |
| Total | $58 | — | $36 | $22 | ($20) |
Next to the table, Westbrook explains the reason for each measurement. For example: equipment with a carrying amount of $48 million was written down to its fair value of $36 million because lower demand reduced its expected cash flows. Because the warehouse and customer list are Level 3, Westbrook also describes the valuation technique and gives quantitative information about the significant unobservable inputs.
The journal entries ($ in millions):
- Equipment: debit Impairment loss $12, credit Equipment (or Accumulated depreciation, depending on company policy) $12.
- Warehouse held for sale: debit Loss on write-down of asset held for sale $4, credit Warehouse $4. The warehouse is now carried at $16, which is its $17 fair value minus $1 cost to sell.
- Customer-list intangible: debit Impairment loss $4, credit Customer-list intangible $4.
Total losses: $12 + $4 + $4 = $20, matching the table.
For the underlying accounting, see the asset impairment test, held for use vs. held for sale, and goodwill impairment.
Highest and best use
Fair value for a nonfinancial asset assumes the use that market participants would find most valuable, called its highest and best use. If that differs from how the company actually uses the asset, the company discloses the difference and why it uses the asset that way.
Hypothetical example. A plant sits on land that developers would buy for housing. Fair value assumes residential redevelopment, but the company keeps operating the plant to supply its customers. It discloses both facts.
Common mistakes
- Including nonrecurring items in the Level 3 reconciliation. The reconciliation is for recurring measurements only.
- Leaving out the reason. Nonrecurring measurements must explain why fair value was measured.
- Confusing fair value with fair value less cost to sell. The disclosure reports fair value; an asset held for sale is carried net of selling costs.
- Remeasuring an impaired asset held and used every period. After the write-down, the impaired amount is the new cost basis.
- Calling goodwill impairment a recurring measurement. Fair value is measured for the reporting unit, not for goodwill itself, and only when goodwill is tested for impairment. The loss is the amount by which the reporting unit’s carrying amount exceeds its fair value, capped at the goodwill balance.
Exam tip: When a question asks you to classify a fair value measurement, look for the trigger. If the item is at fair value on every balance sheet by design, it is recurring. If something happened first, like an impairment, a held for sale decision, or an observable price change, it is nonrecurring. And if a question asks which disclosure is unique to nonrecurring items, the answer is the reason for the measurement.
Interactive fair value practice
Recurring vs. Nonrecurring Fair Value Measurements
Apply ASC 820 to three multiple-choice questions on trading securities, long-lived asset impairment, and fair value hierarchy disclosures. Try the exercise before reviewing the worked answers below.
Practice questions with answers
Question 1: Classify the measurements
Classify each as recurring or nonrecurring: (a) an interest rate swap, (b) a building written down for impairment, (c) trading securities, (d) the reporting unit fair value used to recognize a goodwill impairment loss.
Answer:
(a) Recurring, (b) nonrecurring, (c) recurring, (d) nonrecurring
Derivatives and trading securities are measured at fair value every period. An impairment-related fair value measurement is nonrecurring. Under the general ASC 350 model, goodwill is tested annually and between annual tests when impairment indicators arise. A quantitative test measures the reporting unit’s fair value.
Question 2: Held for sale
A machine classified as held for sale has a carrying amount of $50,000, a fair value of $44,000, and estimated costs to sell of $2,000. What is the loss, the new carrying amount, and the fair value disclosed?
Answer:
Loss $8,000; carrying amount $42,000; fair value disclosed $44,000
Fair value less cost to sell is $44,000 − $2,000 = $42,000, so the loss is $50,000 − $42,000 = $8,000. The disclosure reports the $44,000 fair value measurement.
Question 3: Disclosure difference
Which disclosure is required for a nonrecurring fair value measurement but not for a recurring one?
Answer:
The reason for the measurement
Recurring measurements happen every period by design. Nonrecurring measurements happen because of an event, so the note explains what triggered them.
Want more practice like this? Compare these notes with fair value of financial instruments and the Level 3 reconciliation.
Key takeaways
- Recurring measurements are made every period; nonrecurring measurements only when an event requires them.
- Impairments and assets held for sale are the most common nonrecurring measurements.
- Both types disclose the hierarchy level. Level 2 and Level 3 items also disclose valuation techniques and inputs, and Level 3 items add numbers for the significant unobservable inputs.
- Nonrecurring measurements disclose the reason for the measurement. The full reconciliation applies to recurring Level 3 measurements of public entities.
- Disclose when a nonfinancial asset’s highest and best use differs from its current use.
Frequently asked questions
Is an impaired asset remeasured at fair value every period after the impairment?
No. An impaired asset held and used gets a new cost basis at the impaired amount and is not written back up. The fair value measurement happened once, which is why it is nonrecurring.
Why does the disclosure show $17 million for the warehouse if it is carried at $16 million?
The fair value disclosure reports the fair value measurement itself. The asset held for sale is carried at fair value less cost to sell, so its balance sheet amount is lower by the selling costs.
Do nonrecurring measurements need a Level 3 reconciliation?
No. The reconciliation is required only for recurring Level 3 measurements. Nonrecurring Level 3 measurements still need the valuation technique and quantitative information about significant unobservable inputs.
Is fair value measured for goodwill impairment a nonrecurring measurement?
Yes, when the reporting unit’s fair value is used to recognize a goodwill impairment loss. Under the general ASC 350 model, goodwill is tested annually and between annual tests when impairment indicators arise. A quantitative test compares the reporting unit’s fair value with its carrying amount.
What if fair value assumes a use different from how the company uses the asset?
For a nonfinancial asset, the company discloses that fact and why it uses the asset differently from its highest and best use.
Is a held for sale asset still nonrecurring if it is remeasured every period?
Yes. The measurement is triggered by the held for sale classification, not by a standard that requires fair value on the balance sheet every period. ASC 820’s own illustration presents held for sale assets as nonrecurring.
Are business combination fair values recurring or nonrecurring?
Neither. Acquisition-date fair values are initial recognition, so they fall outside the ASC 820 recurring and nonrecurring tables. ASC 805 has its own disclosure requirements.
Do nonpublic companies have to give the full Level 3 reconciliation?
No. For recurring Level 3 measurements, nonpublic entities separately disclose purchases and issues in lieu of the full rollforward. They also disclose the amounts and reasons for transfers into and out of Level 3, with transfers in and transfers out presented separately.
Sources
- PwC Viewpoint: Financial statement presentation, FSP 20.3 Fair value disclosures (ASC 820-10-50-2)
- Deloitte Roadmap: Fair Value Measurements and Disclosures, Section 11.1
- FASB Accounting Standards Codification, Topic 820: Fair Value Measurement
- IFRS Foundation: IFRS 13 Fair Value Measurement
About the author
Mansour Farhat, CPA, CIA, DBA, teaches accounting and CPA exam review at Farhat Lectures and on the Farhat Lectures YouTube channel.
Continue learning with Farhat Lectures
Strengthen your accounting understanding with clear explanations and guided practice.
Explore the free sample course
Responses